105 E 2nd St in Downtown, Casper, WY

fagan diamond jewelers store interiorFagan Diamond Jewelers specializes in custom made-to-order precious metal jewelry but also carries a beautiful selection of jewelry in stock. Let Nora Fagan design our one of a kind special occasion rings, necklaces, bracelets, and earrings or stop by to see their beautiful selection of fine jewelry.

Fagan Diamond Jewelers only displays natural gem stones in their showroom. The quality matters because the result is more beautiful and your jewelry will retain a better value. Natural gem stones also last longer and require fewer repairs over the lifetime of the jewelry.

Shop Local in Downtown Casper, Wyoming

We are locally owned and operated. It is important to us that you "love" the jewelry you wear. We have a large selection of engagement rings, bracelets, gemstones, and alternative metals including stainless steel, tungsten and titanium.

We Can Help You Create a Timeless Piece of Custom Jewelry

Bring your ideas and we will help you create a unique piece of handcrafted jewelry all your own. We start by putting your ideas into CAD to come up with a plan. Once you approve the design we will craft the piece. We can do remounting, resetting and gold smithing as well. Free estimates on custom jobs and repairs.

30 Day Exchange Program

We offer a 30 day no questions asked exchange program if you are not satisfied with your purchase.

We Buy & Trade for Scrap Gold

You can also use your unwanted gold for credit towards new purchases, repairs or other services. We also buy scrap gold.

Cleaning, Restoration, Repair & Sizing

Bring your jewelry in to Fagan Jewelry for cleaning, repair, ring resizing, restoration or resetting. 

Layaway Program

Fagan Diamond Jewelers offers a layaway program. Learn how it works and make buying fine jewelry easier on your wallet.