105 E 2nd St in Downtown, Casper, WY

We specialize in fine jewelry & gemstones


Welcome to Fagan Jewelry! We are locally owned and operated. We believe you should "love" the jewelry you wear. We have a large selection of engagement rings, earrings, bracelets, gemstones and bling for every budget. Find something special and add it to the Wish Book for later. We have layaway too!

Browse Jewelry

Custom Jewelry & More

Carefully Selected for Superior Quality

Fagan Diamond Jewelers offers custom designed jewelry & engagement rings as well as a carefully selected range of jewelry from top jewelry manufacturers. Drop by our studio located in downtown Casper to design your own custom jewelry piece or to view our collection.

Create a Timeless Piece of Custom Jewelry

custom jewelry wyomingEngagement rings are our specialty; we also design custom jewelry to celebrate any milestone or occassion. Looking for a stunning diamond? We have them! Fagan Diamond Jewelers can get any gem you desire! Looking for a colored or specialty diamond? We can find you any color, shape or quality! We can get specialty gems & diamonds with overnight delivery.

We Buy Scrap Gold

casper scrap gold buyerHave old, unwanted or broken gold jewelry? Bring it in & sell it for cash or trade it for something new.

Shop Local

Shop downtown Casper's LOCAL jewelry store for fine and custom crafted jewelry. We have gifts for any budget. From diamonds and colored gemstones to stunning silver. Necklaces, earrings, bracelets and rings - we will deliver the BLING!